How the size estimate works
The planner adds up an effective length of fish from the largest adult length and how the rest of the group compares, then applies more water per inch for saltwater fish, heavy bioloads, and aggressive temperaments. It also sets a minimum tank length of four to six times the largest fish so it can turn and swim, and rounds up to common tank sizes.
Why it gives a range
Body shape, activity, and husbandry vary too much for one exact number. The smaller size is a practical starting point; the larger size adds stability and dilutes waste between water changes.